Hi Jeff,

I think Wesley and I didn't talk about this specific case, to be honest.

(+Wesley)

Wesley: got any good ideas here? I.e., how does a working group manage a bunch of individual Forum tickets internally, and then push them up -- individually -- up to the main mpi-forum repo?

I think it would be desirable for the working group to be able to make a PDF that represents all their collectively-agreed-upon PRs, but also be able to push those PRs individually up to the Forum (vs. pushing the entire union of all changes up to the Forum en masse).

I think it would be ok to pull something that passed the 2nd vote into mpiwg-tools/mpir:mpir-1.x so new issues and branches can benefit from the updated document/chapter. So what about this workflow: 1. Member creates issue at mpiwg-tools/tools-issues 2. Member creates a branch off mpiwg-tools/mpir:mpir-1.x called issue_<issueno>_<issuename> 3. Member forks off mpiwg-tools/mpir (or rebases?) 4. Member makes changes to local fork and prepares a pull request from <username>/mpir:my_branch_that_handles_issue to mpiwg-tools/mpir:issue_<issueno>_<issuename> 5. If WG feels OK with the pull request, we accept it and create a pull-request of mpiwg-tools/mpir:issue_<issueno>_<issuename> against mpiwg-tools/mpir:mpir-1.x and schedule reading + votes. If anything fails, reiterate from (3), if it passes, mpiwg-tools merges the pull-request and the the "working-group copy" of the document reflects all accepted changes. 6. WG then creates another pull-request from the same branch against mpi-forum/mpir:mpir-1.x so they can be integrated into the _official_ document as soon as whoever is responsible for it is OK with it. We could also have a branch mpiwg-tools/mpir:ticket_zero that collects _all_ ticket zero changes. This way, all the trivial changes of missing commas etc. are in one pull-request and the others can be done at a time. What do you think? Cheers, Marc-Andre -- Marc-Andre Hermanns Jülich Aachen Research Alliance, High Performance Computing (JARA-HPC) Jülich Supercomputing Centre (JSC) Schinkelstrasse 2 52062 Aachen Germany Phone: +49 2461 61 2509 | +49 241 80 24381 Fax: +49 2461 80 6 99753 www.jara.org/jara-hpc email: [email protected]