Hi all,

 

(I've ended up on this ml because of a recent discussion on the OpenMPI ml referring to this user-guide and because I'm working on a parallel financial app that runs in batch-mode but will also be run in online-mode. The calculations are only loosely coupled calculations but stability/fault-tolerance is important when running in batch-mode and certainly when running online)

 

So I ended up reading the user guide (https://svn.mpi-forum.org/trac/mpi-forum-web/wiki/ft/run_through_users_guide) and since it seems destined to app developers like me, I'll provide some feedback from my pov:

 

In the motivation section, paragraph 4: Hopefully not a silly question but what is actually considered to be a failure ? Looking into the archives of this ml there are many discussions on the topic but what is actually the current conclusion?

Additionally, is it possible that a process can detect that the process itself fails, e.g. if its network went down and thus unable to communicate any further.

Finally, I think there is a typo in the first example in the section Point-to-Point operators. It relies on 'status' for knowing the failed rank while IMO it should be 'peer'.

toon