For Groups etc, Page 238, lines 40-41 put the second argument ahead of the first in MPI_Group_incl. Like MPI_Win_test, not incorrect but odd, and different than MPI_Group_excl on the next page. Page 270, lines 47. This is probably ok, but with support for what is equivalent to a void *, shouldn't the extra state parameter use that instead of the pre-Fortran2008 "use an address-sized integer as the value of a pointer or something similar" hack? At least a rationale for sticking with the older Fortran style? I'm not familiar enough with F 2008 to judge the attribute interface, but it looks ok. Otherwise, this chapter is ok (and there are no required changes here). Bill On Sep 21, 2011, at 1:53 AM, Rolf Rabenseifner wrote:

Dear all, especially, dear owners of new MPI-3 tickets, and dear chapter author,

If a review is missing, we need to execute a line-by-line formal reading. I expect that nobody want this.

I hope, you all will return your reviews today (Sep. 21) that I can prepare the ppt with the review-results for the MPI Forum meeting (Sep. 22).

For most chapters, it is mainly to check the argument lists of the new bindings.

Responsible: Special Fortran reviewers: "Jeff Squyres" <[email protected]>; "Craig E Rasmussen" <[email protected]>; (IN SANTORINI) "Hubert Ritzdorf" <[email protected]>; "Purushotham Bangalore" <[email protected]>; "Bill Gropp" <[email protected]>; "Reinhold Bader" <[email protected]> Chapter authors from http://meetings.mpi-forum.org/mpi3.0_chapter_wgs.php - Front matter : Bill Gropp - Introduction : Bill Gropp - Terms and Definitions : Rolf Rabenseifner (IN SANTORINI) - Point-to-Point Communication : Richard Graham (IN SANTORINI) - Datatypes: George Bosilca (IN SANTORINI) - Collective Communication : Adam Moody (IN SANTORINI), Torsten Hoefler (IN SANTORINI), Yutaka Ishikawa, Hideyuki Jitsumoto Who is responsible? - Process Topologies : Torsten Hoefler (IN SANTORINI) - Groups, Contexts, and Communicators : Bill Gropp - Environmental Management : George Bosilca (IN SANTORINI) - Info-Object : Darius Buntinas (IN SANTORINI) - Process Creation and Management : David Solt - One-Sided Communications : Bill Gropp + Rajeev Thakur - External Interfaces : Bronis R. de Supinski - I/O : Rajeev Thakur(c) - Profiling interface : Bronis R. de Supinski + Martin Schulz - Deprecated Functions : Rolf Rabenseifner (IN SANTORINI) - Language Bindings : Jeffrey M. Squyres - Annex Language Bindings Summary : Rolf Rabenseifner (IN SANTORINI) - Annex Change-Log : Rolf Rabenseifner (IN SANTORINI) - Bibliography : Bill Gropp

Best regards Rolf

----- Original Message -----

...

From: "Rolf Rabenseifner" <[email protected]> To: "Jeff Squyres" <[email protected]> Cc: "William Gropp" <[email protected]>, "Hubert Ritzdorf" <[email protected]

...

, "Purushotham Bangalore" <[email protected]>, "Bill Gropp" <[email protected]>, "Reinhold Bader" <[email protected]>, "Richard Graham" <[email protected]>, "George Bosilca" <[email protected]>, "Adam Moody" <[email protected]>, "Torsten Hoefler" <[email protected]>, "David George Solt" <[email protected]>, "Rajeev Thakur" <[email protected]>, "Bronis R. de Supinski" <[email protected]>, "Martin Schulz" <[email protected]>, "Darius Buntinas" <[email protected]>, "Craig E Rasmussen" <[email protected]> Sent: Friday, September 9, 2011 8:54:33 AM Subject: Re: Pre-review - New Fortran bindings - Formal reading Dear all,

It is a really huge ticket that needs the review-support of all chapter responsibles. I try to sort it out:

A) Normal chapter-reviewers: Officially, reviewers have to review always the reviewdoc, i.e., mpi-report-F2008-2011-09-08-reviewdoc.pdf This means, one must mainly review the diff, i.e., the red portions marked with ticket. This is recommended for the normal chapter reviewers.

B) Fortran-Chapter-Reviewers: For Section 16.2 "Fortran Support", it is strongly recommended to review mpi-report-F2008-2011-09-08-changeonlyplustickets.pdf because this is the only readable form of this section. This means one must read the total Section 16.2 as a whole (black and red).

C) For owners of MPI-3 tickets: Please take mpi-report-F2008-2011-09-08-changeonlyplustickets.pdf and check for Annex B.4. The interfaces are always two: - the new mpif_f08 - and the old mpi. The old one (i.e., the second form) must be checked whether it is identical to your latest version of your ticket. The new one (i.e., the first form) must be checked whether it is correctly mapped to mpi_f08.

D) All: If one wants to make handwritten marks, for example on travel, then I recommend to print mpi-report-F2008-2011-09-08-changeonlyplustickets_majorpages.pdf and in mpi-report-F2008-2011-09-08-changeonlyplustickets.pdf the Annexes A.3 (p.553-695) and B.4 (p.753-770).

As already said, it is huge. It touches 140 pages (...majorpages.pdf) and contains 43 pages of new interfaces for MPI-2.2 (Annex A.3) and additionally 18 pages for MPI-3.0 tickets (Annex B.4)

E) Compilation-Check: If you want compile the module interface, then you must download mpi-3.0-all-interfaces-08-f2003.f90

F) If you want to see, how it looks like in the future if you have a F2008+TR29113 compiler, then you must look at mpi-3.0-all-interfaces-12-f2008TR29113.f90

G) and finally, the file mpi-3.0-all-interfaces-07-f2008.f90 contains exactly what is part of the pdf files Annex A.3. To be more exact, this is the starting point of all the interfaces in the pdf files and of the other two .f90 files. All is done by a set of macros, translating this only one basis into Latex and real Fortran F2003 and F2008+TR29113. (the .2 version is a double uploading, it should be removed but I have no rights to remove such duplicated files Jeff may help?)

Best regards Rolf

----- Original Message -----

...

From: "Jeff Squyres" <[email protected]> To: "Rolf Rabenseifner" <[email protected]> Cc: "William Gropp" <[email protected]>, "Hubert Ritzdorf" <[email protected]>, "Purushotham Bangalore" <[email protected]>, "Bill Gropp" <[email protected]>, "Reinhold Bader" <[email protected]>, "Richard Graham" <[email protected]>, "George Bosilca" <[email protected]>, "Adam Moody" <[email protected]>, "Torsten Hoefler" <[email protected]>, "David George Solt" <[email protected]>, "Rajeev Thakur" <[email protected]>, "Bronis R. de Supinski" <[email protected]>, "Martin Schulz" <[email protected]>, "Darius Buntinas" <[email protected]>, "Craig E Rasmussen" <[email protected]> Sent: Friday, September 9, 2011 12:28:23 AM Subject: Re: Pre-review - New Fortran bindings - Formal reading Rolf --

I see 7 files attached to the ticket from today. Which one are we supposed to review?

mpi-report-F2008-2011-09-08-changeonlyplustickets_majorpages.pdf (843.5 KB) - added by RolfRabenseifner 2 hours ago. Updated version for reading/reviewing at MPI Forum meeting Sep 2011 - deleted text is invisible - major pages for printing mpi-report-F2008-2011-09-08-changeonlyplustickets.pdf (4.0 MB) - added by RolfRabenseifner 2 hours ago. Updated version for reading/reviewing at MPI Forum meeting Sep 2011 - deleted text is invisible mpi-report-F2008-2011-09-08-reviewdoc.pdf (4.1 MB) - added by RolfRabenseifner 2 hours ago. Updated version for reading/reviewing at MPI Forum meeting Sep 2011 - deleted text is still visible mpi-3.0-all-interfaces-07-f2008.f90 (90.3 KB) - added by RolfRabenseifner 2 hours ago. mpi_f08 binding used in the MPI draft 2011-09-08 mpi-3.0-all-interfaces-07-f2008.2.f90 (90.3 KB) - added by RolfRabenseifner 2 hours ago. mpi_f08 binding used in the MPI draft 2011-09-08 mpi-3.0-all-interfaces-08-f2003.f90 (184.1 KB) - added by RolfRabenseifner 2 hours ago. mpi_f08 module, preliminary implementation with Fortran 2003 mpi-3.0-all-interfaces-12-f2008TR29113.f90 (175.8 KB) - added by RolfRabenseifner 2 hours ago. mpi_f08 module, final implementation for Fortran2008+TR29113 compiler

On Sep 8, 2011, at 4:51 PM, Rolf Rabenseifner wrote:

...

Dear reviewers,

Many thanks for the pre-reviews especially to Jeff, Reinhold, Craig, Hubert, Puri, Martin, Rajeev, Darius, George, Bill, and Bronis.

My apologies that I had to few time for answering individually.

All (or nearly all) is included in this final version. I expect there are still bugs but I hope that we can get them fixed after your final reviews in a new ticket.

This version should go into your reviews, in the formal reading and through the two votes.

All files are attached to the ticket https://svn.mpi-forum.org/trac/mpi-forum-web/attachment/ticket/229/

The review should be based only on the latest pdf-files from 2011-09-08. The content of the tickets is not updated, it tells only some reasons in a very early state. Some of these reasons are now rationales in the document.

Please finish your review on the day before the meeting starts, i.e., not later than

September 21.

Most of you are responsible for one or more chapters. If you do not speak Fortran, I expect, that you organized already a colleague who assists you in reviewing.

If new MPI-3 tickets will go into your chapter, you should also review Annex B.4 that contains already interfaces for those tickets.

Responsible: Special Fortran reviewers: "Jeff Squyres" <[email protected]>; "Craig E Rasmussen" <[email protected]>; "Hubert Ritzdorf" <[email protected]>; "Purushotham Bangalore" <[email protected]>; "Bill Gropp" <[email protected]>; "Reinhold Bader" <[email protected]> Chapter authors from http://meetings.mpi-forum.org/mpi3.0_chapter_wgs.php - Front matter : Bill Gropp - Introduction : Bill Gropp - Terms and Definitions : Rolf Rabenseifner - Point-to-Point Communication : Richard Graham - Datatypes: George Bosilca - Collective Communication : Adam Moody, Torsten Hoefler, Yutaka Ishikawa, Hideyuki Jitsumoto Who is responsible? - Process Topologies : Torsten Hoefler - Groups, Contexts, and Communicators : Bill Gropp - Environmental Management : George Bosilca - Info-Object : Darius Buntinas - Process Creation and Management : David Solt - One-Sided Communications : Bill Gropp + Rajeev Thakur - External Interfaces : Bronis R. de Supinski - I/O : Rajeev Thakur(c) - Profiling interface : Bronis R. de Supinski + Martin Schulz - Deprecated Functions : Rolf Rabenseifner - Language Bindings : Jeffrey M. Squyres - Annex Language Bindings Summary : Rolf Rabenseifner - Annex Change-Log : Rolf Rabenseifner - Bibliography : Bill Gropp

Best regards Rolf

-- Jeff Squyres [email protected] For corporate legal information go to: http://www.cisco.com/web/about/doing_business/legal/cri/

--

-- Dr. Rolf Rabenseifner . . . . . . . . . .. email [email protected] High Performance Computing Center (HLRS) . phone ++49(0)711/685-65530 University of Stuttgart . . . . . . . . .. fax ++49(0)711 / 685-65832 Head of Dpmt Parallel Computing . . . www.hlrs.de/people/rabenseifner Nobelstr. 19, D-70550 Stuttgart, Germany . (Office: Allmandring 30) _______________________________________________ mpi-forum mailing list [email protected] http://lists.mpi-forum.org/mailman/listinfo.cgi/mpi-forum

William Gropp Director, Parallel Computing Institute Deputy Director for Research Institute for Advanced Computing Applications and Technologies Paul and Cynthia Saylor Professor of Computer Science University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign